Showing posts with label prior art. Show all posts
Showing posts with label prior art. Show all posts

Monday, August 15, 2011

Must Read Monday: Kan Zu On The Art Of Patent Enforcement

Medium shifting from Sun Tzu to Kan Zu:
patents instead of arms,
LED screen instead of bamboo

Sun Tzu wrote about the Art of War. Competition between companies is a kind of war, whereby the only potential fatality is the bankruptcy of a company. The offensive and defensive weaponry are patents. Kan Zu, attorney at Unitalen, wrote as a modern day Sun Tzu a highly interesting treatise on patents: 'The Influence of New Patent Law and Interpretation on Patent Enforcement in China'. It deals with double patenting, design patents, claim construction and interpretation, doctrine of equivalents and file wrapper estoppel, means-plus-function claims, prior art defenses, declaratory judgments and remedies.


Prepare for battle, read Kan Zu's article here.
continue reading ...

Tuesday, May 05, 2009

Professor Mossoff's Historical Paper About Patent Thicket, Patent Troll and Patent Pool: Relevant Today

Can we learn from history? Or are we doomed to make the same mistakes over and over? Professor Adam Mossoff of George Mason University School of Law wrote an excellent paper about the Sewing Machine War of the 1850's which illustrates that the challenges we are facing in this day and age with patent thickets, patent trolls and patent pools are not new. Professor Mossoff draws the conclusion that "[t]he denouement of the sewing machine patent thicket in the Sewing Machine Combination of 1856, the first privately formed patent pool, further challenges the widely held belief that patent thickets are best solved through new statutes, regulations or court decisions that limit property rights in patents."

The paper illustrates in great style the titanic battle between Elias Howe (who did not do anything other with the patent then using it for injunctions to compel licenses from manufacturers) and Isaac Merritt Singer (who was an incremental inventor). In this battle Singer was looking for prior art to invalidate Howe's patent:

"Singer first attempted to uncover prior art in the patent offices in England, France, and, of course, the United States, and he even went so far as to argue that the sewing machine had long been invented in China, but this was all to no avail."

Download and read professor Mossoff's great SSRN-paper 'A Stitch in Time: The Rise and Fall of the Sewing Machine Patent Thicket', here (52 pages PDF).
continue reading ...

Thursday, January 17, 2008

Patent Challenge in China: What's the State of the Art?

The last quarterly newsletter of the European Patent Office (EPO) has an interesting article about the difficulty for foreign patent applicants to determine prior art (state of the art) in China, because all prior art in China is in Chinese. To determine prior art is crucial, because the patent can only be granted to an invention that is both new and inventive. So what is already known and what is new in China if you cannot search in and read Chinese? Machine tranlations are expected to be possible in three years time.Mr. Ruud Peters, CEO of Philips Intellectual Property and Standards, who spoke at the EPO Patent Information Conference in Riga criticised "missing out the increasingly large collection of Chinese prior art". The translations of only the claims from Chinese into English is estimated to be 15 million euro per year. The EPO would like the funding to be done in a way that allows that the translations are published for free online, Commercial companies such as Thomson Scientific, East Linden and Beijing Zhongxian Tuofang Co. Ltd. of course want to earn money for their translations. Mr. Peters had some harsh words about the patent system in relation to China: "stifling" instead of "stimulating innovation". Then again, an amendment of the Chinese patent law is coming up, so maybe all is not so bleak.
Read the EPO article here.
continue reading ...