Taiwan IP Update: First Country That Protects Hologram In Its Trademark Law

Taiwan has amended its Trademark Act May 31, 2011. What has changed?

Progressive trademark act,
but with olfactory deficiency
Photo: NASA via Wikipedia

• Listing counterfeit merchandise online will be punishable by fines of up to NT$50,000 and up to one year in prison. 

According to the director-general of Taiwan Intellectual Property Office (TIPO), Wang Mei-hua (王美花) the scope of trademark protection expanded to include: 

• animation (movement) and laser logors (hologram);
• three-dimensional shape, colour and sound, already since the Examination Guideline for 3D, Colour and Sound Marks on 1st July 2004;
• and already since the Trademark Act November 2003 word; figure and symbol. 

Some argue that holograms are not perceived as sources of origin by consumers. But one can also argue that that article 15 (1) Trade-related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPs) does include holograms: "Any sign, or any combination of signs, capable of distinguishing the goods or services of one undertaking from those of other undertakings, shall be capable of constituting a trademark. Such signs, in particular words including personal names, letters, numerals, figurative elements and combinations of colours as well as any combination of such signs, shall be eligible for registration as trademarks. Where signs are not inherently ca pable of distinguishing the relevant goods or services, Members may make registrability depend on distinctiveness acquired through use. Members may require, as a condition of registration, that signs be visually perceptible.", most jurisdictions perceive some problems with the prescription of the last sentence that the representation needs to be graphically representable. Taiwan (Chinese Taipei) has become a member of the WTO of which TRIPs is an integral part on January 1, 2002.

Now a hologram's graphical representation changes per definition according to the angle you are taking towards it. However, since most intellectual property offices around the world already record the representations digitally, I think it should not have to be an insurmountable problem, as everybody who in the last few years bought a digital camera knows that these cameras include a movie function. So instead of photos, you can easily also make a very high quality movie of any dynamic representation. And even if you insist upon static photo's, there are cameras that can make a series of stills, each separated from the other by a fraction of a second.
 
The International Hologram Manufacturers Association (IHMA) is thrilled that Taiwan is the first country to protect holograms as a trademark. According to IHMA, Holograms can play a role in the authentication and detection process against counterfeit products, read here.  

Take notice that Taiwan is not taking the lead in every trademarkable representation. Scent is not specified as protectable representation. However, in case companies register it, TIPO will study executive orders.

Read more about non-traditional trademarks in the archives of Dr. Ralph Sieckmann, here.

• No longer is there a minimum limit for trademark infringement fines of 500 times the unit retail price of the infringed goods. Judges will have full discretion about the amount of the fine. 
• Applicants for certificates of origin (Taiwan's Geographical Indications) will have to use the location of origin or the logo identifying the location in their application in accordance with the Trademark Act. 

Read the China Post article here.

continue reading ...

In The Year of The Tigger: What Makes A Real Winnie The Pooh?

How to tell real from fake?

On top: real Winnie the Pooh, including a laser hologram of Walt Disney.

Below: fake Winnie the Pooh, without a laser hologram of Walt Disney. The counterfeit one is on offer in Wanchai, Hong Kong for 30 HK dollar (about 3 euro) and is tailor made for Chinese new year (good year's wishes and two plush oranges).

Probably the counterfeiters will learn from Walt Disney and might come up with their own hologram. And Walt Disney could learn from the counterfeit version and come up with a tailor made Chinese new year Winnie.

Thank you for the pictures Trinity!

continue reading ...

New Technology for Old Wines Against Counterfeit Bottles

"In China and Vietnam, you find more counterfeit than authentic bottles,'' Serge Tchekhov said in a phone interview with Elin McCoy of Bloomberg.

In order to fight counterfeit wines winemakers are considering to deploy new technologies such as RFID, now that holograms obviously are replicated too easily by counterfeiters, see Genuine Fake Holograms From China here.

Tchekhov now works with Swiss wine-security company Algoril. Before he was working as wine expert for a commission to fight counterfeiting, set up by France's offical printing company Imprimerie Nationale, under the Finance Ministry in 2004. Its study showed counterfeits accounted for about 9 percent of the global economy.

Read McCoy's article about new ways to guarantee the authenticity of wines here.

Unmentioned in the article but even more important, however of a much smaller scale, is the problem of authentic bottles with fake wine. Technology that shows whether a bottle has been opened or not should guarantee this is not the case. Otherwise only a connaisseur might taste the difference.

continue reading ...

Genuine Fake Holograms From China

Marty Graham wrote an article about counterfeited holograms for Wired News.

Graham explains that as the counterfeited products increase in value, the sooner counterfeited holograms are added to fake genuineness of the products. The technology to copy holograms has been diffused around the world. So counterfeiters can either copy it themselves, buy it from hologram counterfeiters or buying the real holograms from the backdoor.

"Twenty years ago, the technology to duplicate holograms was carefully guarded where now it's widely diffused," says Ed Dietrich, who has worked on hologram security issues for more than 20 years. "There are lots of little companies in China, for example, that make holograms now -- not to say that's good or bad, just that the technology is diffused."

The article questions the raison d'être of holograms, because the consumers cannot tell the difference between fake and genuine holograms. However, scanning machines in the hands of customs could make searching for fakes holograms more effective.

Read Graham's article here.

continue reading ...